The Clubhouse Podcast

iTunes Exclusive Episode Petes Dragon

May 6, 2018 Season 7, Episode 99

Rob, Chad, and Don review Disney's Pete's Dragon, directed by David Lowry. Rob and Chad enjoyed the film for its emotional themes and family dynamics, while Don found the dragon's design unconvincing and the second half too predictable. The hosts debate the film's merits while respecting each other's differing opinions on this live-action/CGI remake.

About this episode

Key takeaways

  • Pete's Dragon is a reimagining rather than a straight remake, with nearly completely different plot, characters, and setting from the 1977 original
  • The film explores themes of friendship and family that emotionally resonated with viewers, though some felt the emotional beats were pushed too hard
  • The dragon's furry design proved divisive—one host found it resembled Sulley from Monsters Inc. rather than a traditional scaled dragon, while others accepted it within the family film context
  • Robert Redford, Bryce Dallas Howard, and other cast members delivered strong performances that elevated the material

Q&A

How does the plot of the 2016 Pete's Dragon differ from the 1977 original?

The plots are almost completely different. In this version, Pete is orphaned as a child and lives in the woods with a dragon named Elliott for six years before being discovered by park ranger Grace and brought to live with her family.

What was one of Don's main criticisms of the film?

Don felt the dragon's furry design didn't resemble a classic dragon—he associated it with Sulley from Monsters Inc. and the three-headed dog from Harry Potter rather than traditional scaled dragons. He also found the second half too predictable and felt the film pushed emotions too hard on the audience.

How did the hosts rate the 3D experience?

Chad felt the 3D didn't add much depth except during aerial shots with perspective, while Rob noted the 3D in BFG was better.

Would the hosts watch this film again?

Chad would pay full price for an evening theater showing. Rob would see it again if taking people who haven't seen it, ideally with kids. Don said he probably wouldn't watch it again personally but could recommend it as a matinee for families.

Read Transcript

Greetings, Empire Member and Ormembers. If you are hearing the sound of my voice, it means the following conditions have been met. At least once in your life, you have listened to the clubhouse podcast live every Sunday, 9-7 Eastern for Pacific, your one-stop shop for all things sports and entertainment.

It also means you subscribe to the show on iTunes because this time for another, ah, tunes a squishy baby. Welcome, it is the 227th one of these things. My name is Rob, I'm the executive producer of the clubhouse podcast, and I have a really vivid imagination that I'm not afraid to say it, tell our role, tell me get down, it's what I do.

I'm not alone for this particular episode because I very rarely have ram. Joining me across the desk is a man who, at least at one point in his childhood, believed in dragons because we all did, he has Chad. Welcome, sir.

I still do. But only if there's a game of thrones involved, maybe. No, not necessarily.

I have a spirit animal, he's a dragon. Mine's an awkward turtle. Also joining us is the official fact checker of this show, and a man who may have some HSOs in this episode.

You may know in this fun, don, go, but it's mom and name him, Don Ford, I'm going to come Don Ford. Welcome, sir. HSOs.

A hot sports opinion. Okay. But hey, I believe in dragons.

No dragons. Come on, dragons. That's right.

Well, we got one that lives in this house. It's a matter of fact. Whatever we do one of these things, it is to review something today is no different.

We're dipping into the Disney well today, kids, because Pete's dragon has returned almost 30 years later, actually a little over 30 years, no, just short, just under 30. I've really got to get my math skills under control. As director David Lowry, who did ink them, body saints brings us the remake of Pete's dragon from the, from the, from our friends at the Walt Disney Company.

First up, before we start this whole thing, we got to think Susan, Jen, everybody, Susan Jacobs and Disney for the invite. You know, it was great to see Susan at the screen. She was sitting right behind us, and they do such great work over there, Jen is so amazing.

We love those people. We're so excited. So thankful that they love to get us, but let us, let us do these things.

What is going on with me and talking today? You're just rushing. Slow down, and that's been a long week.

Conchegate the verse. Okay. So to say this is a remake of Pete's dragon might be a little bit presumptious, because really, to reimagining.

I would say it's a reimagining, because really the only things these things have in common repeat in the dragon. Right. Oh, they, I mean, I, I've told you this before, but in the Empire now, I haven't seen the original in decades.

I kind of like barely remember the outside of Star Wars. Outside of Star Wars, this film owned my childhood. Okay.

I had the view master. But it's been a long time. I mean, do they, so a week we get into this later, but I just want to know later if the plots, how much are they do really different stuff like that?

Oh, yeah. They're almost completely different. It's, in this particular telling, Pete is basically orphaned as a child due to a tragedy, and basically is living in the woods with a dragon whom he named Elliott.

Six years after the accident, he is discovered by a park ranger, played by the great Bryce Dallas Howard, whose name is Grace. She ends up taking him back with her to live with her, and there's all kinds of things going on here. She's about to get married to a guy named Jack and Jack's brother, Gavin, and basically excavating some of the woods, and Jack's not a really nice guy, and then you've got their daughter Natalie, or you've got Jack's daughter Natalie, who Grace is about to marry in.

She's the one that actually finds Pete in the forest, and then there's also Grace's dad, meet him, played by the great Robert Redford. There's a lot going on here. It's not suicide, it's quite a lot going on here, but there's a lot going on here.

But it all kind of works out together. Right. It's about an hour, 40, which is a little bit longer than your standard Disney fair, which is fine.

But I didn't really have, I think I was a little worried about the first 10, 15 minute scene to drag a little bit for me, but once it got its feet underneath it, to me, we were off to the races. I mean, you're talking about people like Oaks Fegley, who you might remember from the last season of Boardwalk Empire, playing the young Eli, Una Lawrence, who you might remember as the daughter from Southpaw in an amazing performance, great film, West Bentley plays Jack, Carl Urban plays Gavin, Isaiah Whitlock Jr, who you might remember from a little thing called the Wider, is in this as well. I wanted to hate this film, I'm just going to say, I know you did, you did this, this movie means so much to me when I was a kid.

Like I said, outside of Star Wars, this was the movie. And then I was seeing trailers for this thing, and I was like, easy killer, something just beeped. Was that you?

But that I know it. I was kind of like easy killer, easy on this. And then I was seeing more trailers, and I'm going to be called on.

This is not, there's, there's an ill wind blowing here. Yeah, you were, you were really worked up over there. I want, to me, Dragon shouldn't have fur.

You breathe fire, furs a bad idea, and we'll get into that. So I'm even as I'm walking into theater, I'm like, I'm prepared to leave this, I'm prepared to leave this theater angry, fully prepared. Now, not, not a cup, angry, but I am prepared to be let down.

So if it sucks, I'm going to be okay because I'm prepared for that, right? Like how we felt when we saw a whiplash last year. As I texted you after the film, five words, two sentences, well played Disney, well played 10 minutes in, and I'm emotionally invested because they hook you click.

They do, they really, really do. And this, for me, this just worked on so many levels. Now levels that I wasn't even expecting it to work.

Like the, the, the friendship theme, the family theme, just hitting you in the fields when you need to be hitting the fields. It was, whereas the first one, the original from 77, which you have much fonder memories of than I do. I was never a real fan of the, as I put in my written review at www.clobastpodcast.com.

Which is our website, that these, that the aesthetic, that the 70s Disney Studios films had, they all kind of had this pie in the sky, kind of, they were all very 70s, let's just just, yes, yeah, they were all, they're mostly hokey cornball, but I was, but that was, I don't, and that, but we didn't know, like we mentioned the witch mountain films, huge fan of those. They ever got into them. You mentioned the Apple dumpling game films, huge fan of those.

So as I'm reading here review, I'm like, not really, you know, not really helping my kids cause with me because I don't know, I mean, I'm, I'm, I'm, I'm, I was trying to set up like where we were, where we were in the 70s with Disney, with those examples, you don't to tennis, to where tennis shoes and condo manly, the computer that worked, what did I say? So the tennis that worked. The tennis, the tennis, okay, the black hole and, and condo man, we're my two favorites from this.

Oh God. So condo or man, I enjoyed the black hole, I enjoyed because I think I was too young to really see all the drug and do some references towards the end of it, watching it as an adult going. Wow.

This doesn't hold up. Yeah. And it, like, the abyss ended.

Yeah. We had this great action film and all of a sudden it became, it became 3,000, yeah, I'm just like, I have a question. Yeah.

But they, you know, they all kind of had this look to it and so they were trying to go with the melding of, of their, of their other worlds in, in animation that they've done it twice before with Mary Poppins and Bed Dobs and broomsticks, two varying degrees of success. Mary Poppins was a massive, which we're getting on a remake of by the way, indeed. And the director of this film is going to be doing, I don't know if you saw what am I really, they were, they were going to be doing the remake of Peter Pan that Disney's going to be doing, which is going to of course come after Beauty and the Beast, which is next year.

Very, and Vossal, very happy to know that this guy's local. The, uh, represent graduate from, from Irving High School, right, just read from my office. So, you know, it's, it kind of does my heart good to see that, but it, to me, this film didn't seem like it was really ripe for a remake because I don't think it had that much of an impact outside of very young young kids that embraced it like much like you did.

I think that, if this had been a straight remake, it would have gotten the Charles Barkley rating. Yeah, turbo or if they were doing it, the way they did it. Now, they just done straight animation.

Right. The animation. It probably would have put a bit.

They kind of got smart with it because Larry also co-wrote this. So they were, I think they just had on to it and they're like, look, if we're going to do this, we have to change the bit. Right.

And that concern me, of course, going in. I was released. But I didn't want the fatally family, but the deeper this thing went, the more relaxed I got, like, there was on us to God emotion in me as I'm watching this film, just because of the overall theme, I lost track at how many times I welled up.

Now, we have invented our opinions, I'm going to be over here, biting a piece of metal, go to the other side of the coin, because even before we recorded this, we already had our written reviews up at www.theclubhousepodcast.com, which is our website. So I know what's about to happen, and if you've read the reviews before you've listened to this, you also know what is about to happen. Let us say upfront, one thing that we, one of the core values of this show is we respect each other's opinions.

We do. That being said, I give down the floor. Now, first off, we've been with Susan Jacobs for a long time, and they want our opinion.

Huge fan. Yep. And we appreciate that they want our opinion.

I had a couple of problems with this film, and one thing I could not get over is the Dragon itself. Okay. It reminded me so much of solely from Monsters Inc.

You did say that as the film ended, as you were getting ready to leave. I mean, they're not remind me of a Dragon. When I think of Dragon, I think of Dragons from like Pete's Dragon.

I think of Dragons from Game of Thrones, and the image of that Dragon just did not work for me. Even before the film started, a fellow critic said, we brought up the point that probably it's furry, because it was getting right next to you. Yeah, we're gonna rename name, but this critic said, well, the thing if they make it furry, they could sell a lot more of these at the Disney stores than if they're scaled and stuff like that.

And I totally understood where you were coming from on that, and I thought I was going to have that same. I did. I just cannot get over that for some reason.

It just did not remind me of what you think of a classic Dragon. When it was a friendly dragon, they still have scales, they don't have fur, because if they brief fire, they're going to be burning themselves up, because I was right there with you. Exactly.

But the deeper I got into it, it was the weirdest thing. I just couldn't get over. Kind of remind me, also like the three-headed dog from the first Harry Potter film, you know, it just had that look of like it did not remind me of a dragon.

That was one thing that I just cannot get over unfortunately. The other thing is the film, I understand, I respect you guys as a opinion and everything like that. Even for a family film, I could thought the first half, I really kind of liked, but the last half, I just thought I got two way, way too predictable.

And I think they really tried to press the emotions out into the audience. They tried to really, you know, you always say the cheap pops of the employee, they try to do the cheap emotions where they really try to press the emotions onto you and just instead of letting a film do it. They try to push the envelope on trying to get you emotional.

I can see how you would say that definitely. And I mean, there's some great things, acting going be wrong, right? You know how much of a fan of an oon, I am, and you got red for gnaw, that's stuff in the CGI was incredible.

It's just that those were the two big hurdles I just cannot get over on. But I guess for me, I just looked at it through the lenses of this is a kid's movie. I understand it.

So you kind of have to simplify it. So I guess that's why it did bother me like it bothered you. The last time I got, even for a kid's film, I thought it was too predictable.

I just thought myself. There were moments that I honestly laughed out loud, yeah, you know. There were moments where I was, you know, fighting back the sniffles a little bit, not going to lie to you.

I didn't even find it. I mean, don't worry. I mean, there's a lot of great things, there's just a couple of things I just cannot get over unfortunately.

And you know what? I can watch Bryce tell us how I read the phone book. I'm okay with that.

Yeah. And side note, yeah, I still haven't seen the last thing you big movie she did or which we won't mention on this podcast. But that's a different issue.

Yeah. Uh, again, I really enjoyed this. I adore this film.

It is probably my favorite film of the year so far. Wow. So we've both, you and I have both established our top of the list at this point in the year within the last week, we're last week and a half, really, because we reviewed another film last week that I am putting at the top of my list currently.

This one right now, I believe still sits in the top 10 with three and a half months to go in the year, um, there's that, no, yeah, three and a half somewhere around there somewhere in that neighborhood. Again, it's a public school math. We can do.

Go for it. No, three and a half. Because we're in August.

So you'll have several October and we're about halfway through August now. I'm not going to say my favorite film of the year, but right now it is sitting in the top 10. Now of course, a lot of room to maneuver because there's a lot of time left.

Yeah. Yeah, but this is going to be nowhere near my bottom of the list at all and it just everything worked for me and I'm glad it did because my hope for this film is that there are kids that are going to feel about this film, the way I felt about the original. And I think that's what they're going for and I hope so because now you have our generation who has these kids and in some cases, their kids have kids and you can share that experience with them because you know, sometimes you go back and you look at those films from our kid from our childhood and kids are just like, yeah, I got nothing because on a certain level, they've been kind of spoiled by modern effects.

Yeah, I mean, I tried to read this at the original and I'm like, oh, God, this is an age. Well, but the story backs it up too for me, even though Don felt it was like inside out. Zootopia.

I love those plots. They were great plots, loved everything about it for something for some reason this one just didn't quite. I hate to say it reminded me of left behind and how they tried to really push the motion I think they did on this one too.

Okay. Fair enough. Yeah.

Are we ready to do a final analysis here? Sure. The way we do the final analysis on this show is kind of different if you've never joined us before.

We're not going to give you thumbs up thumbs down. We're not going to give you stars. We're not going to give you letters, numbers, anything like that.

Our audience, whom we affectionately refer to as the Empire, they want us to dig a little deeper. We're going to dig a little deeper. There's up to two questions that will be asked in this question number one I'm going to ask of these gentlemen, is would you see this film again?

If the answer is no, then we're done here. But if the answer is yes, then I move to the second question is to see it again how far you're willing to go. So from the spectrum runs from top to bottom as follows.

Top ranking is I would pay for it at an evening show full price. Below that we go to Twilight, Matt and A, early morning, second run at the dollar theater, bedbox, Netflix, table, Chad, would you see Pete's Dragon again? And I am X 3D, Dolby Atmos, whatever.

And you know what, let's address that for just real quick too. We did see it in 3D. The 3D didn't do much for me in this one.

Anything involving flight. And if you've got a perspective of the person on the, yeah, anytime you take aerial shots, I love it in 3D because there just wasn't, for me there just wasn't the depth that normally 3D does. But still.

So Chad, Chad's putting it on top of the list here. Dom, would you see this film again? No.

I'm being on. Hey, you're honestly, is what we ask? I mean, we don't have to agree with it.

But I'm being honest with you guys that I probably won't watch this again. It's just, I just didn't, didn't catch for me, you know. But I could steal to the families.

I could still recommend it as a matinee to the families. Okay, you know, but I just personally won't see it again. First, I felt like this was the film that BFG wasn't for Disney.

I will agree with you on that front. Although I thought the 3D and BFG was better. Yeah.

Oh, yeah. I would, I will definitely see this again. I will probably own this.

Oh, I will win. It's available on home formats. I would go pay for price at a theater.

But I would have to have people with me that hadn't seen it. Yeah, you know, maybe somebody that's got kids that once ago, or maybe they don't want to go and their kids do. And I'll just hop him in the car and let's go.

I'd love to take my daughter to this. I think she'd love it. It's, I mean, I really enjoyed it.

It was kind of split in the room. But that's okay. I mean, that's why we do what we do.

Yeah, again, before we end this thing, we got to see this in 3D. So we got to get him got to think. Susan, Jen, everybody, it's Susan Jacobs and the great people of Disney.

They do such a great job. Oh, great people. They give us the opportunity to review these films for the empire in advance of them actually releasing.

So we can give you our opinions. And hopefully we'll help you make good choices. Because that's what we try to do on this show.

Again, it is the new version of Peach Dragon directed by David Lauer, a gentleman. Let's do the plugs. Visit our website, the aforementioned www.thuclubhousepodcast.com.

Find out everything you need to know in some stuff you don't. Both are Facebook and our Instagram are the exact same. Look up the Clubhouse podcast.

Please use all three words. You're going to wind up somewhere different if you don't. Our Twitter feed is at Clubhouse Show.

Me, my Twitter feed and my Instagram are exactly the same. They are both, yes, that Rob Urban, that has spelled ERVIN. I'm at chat in PG69 on Twitter.

I'm at fondango and you can email me at Don at the Clubhousepodcast.com. Email Don for information how we can come do live shows with your particular establishment. We love doing live remote shows.

And we're coming up on the fall. So we know we've got a couple to do. You can email me if you'd like questions, comments, concerns.

Tell me to go out and say, I am Rob at the Clubhousepodcast.com. I am Chad at the Clubhousepodcast.com. Charlotte Parker is on Pinterest because we are morally obligated to say that.

And Jules Wormick, good times? Oh, yeah. Well, Charlotte?

Good time. Absolutely. Yeah.

Our normal show every Sunday night at seven Eastern for Pacific is your one-stop shop for all things pop culture. So until next time, for Don, for Chad, for the Empire, I'm Rob. Clubhouse is close.

Brittany Palmer. Just working with Bryce Dallas Howard as a park ranger. I'm telling you.

I'm telling you.

Scroll to Top