Signal 51 Chronicles

The Skull in the Scrubland, a $10K Jailhouse Tip & Pistol Pete’s Easy Ride | Travis Riddle Pt. 2

November 18, 2026

Retired ATF Special Agent in Charge Travis Riddle discusses the Colleyville bomb case outcome and a remarkable jailhouse tip that led to solving a homicide. David Barouche purchased information from inmate Eddie Joe Sutton for $10,000 about a murder victim, murder weapon, and suspect in Anson County. Despite investigators finding the victim's cranium and the firearm, federal prosecutors declined to use the evidence in Barouche's sentencing hearing, fearing Judge McBride would view the purchased tip unfavorably, leaving Barouche without credit for substantial assistance.

About this episode

Key takeaways

  • Federal sentencing guidelines provided a recommended window, but Judge McBride was statutorily capped at ten years maximum for the explosive device charge despite wanting to impose more
  • An inmate sold the same homicide story multiple times to different prisoners for money, attempting to generate funds for his daughter while in poor health
  • Investigators used an ATF canine trained to detect firearms to locate the murder weapon within a quarter-mile search area in rural Texas scrubland
  • The University of North Texas forensic anthropology school conducted a methodical archaeological-style excavation at the suspected burial site
  • Federal prosecutors chose not to present the discovered evidence in court due to concerns about how the judge would view information obtained through purchase

Chapters

  1. 0:00Introduction and Banter

    Hosts John Henry and Jake White open the show with producer Ashley, setting up the Signal 51 Chronicles format.

  2. 2:31Recap: The Colleyville Package Case

    The hosts reconnect with retired ATF SAC Travis Riddle to recap the guilty plea and sentencing in the Colleyville explosive device case.

  3. 10:03Federal vs. State Sentencing Explained

    Travis breaks down federal sentencing guidelines, statutory caps, and why the case went federal instead of state.

  4. 15:12Judge McBride Courtroom Stories

    Travis shares memorable (and funny in hindsight) stories about Judge McBride's strict courtroom demeanor.

  5. 18:42The Jailhouse Proffer and a Bizarre Tip

    Travis describes receiving a proffer from the defendant claiming knowledge of an unrelated homicide, complete with a hand-drawn map.

  6. 20:10Searching the Texas Scrub

    Travis details the search for a shallow grave based on the map, leading to an unexpected discovery.

  7. 24:51Finding the Murder Weapon

    Using an ATF canine, the team locates the firearm tied to the alleged homicide, deepening the mystery.

  8. 26:20The Jailhouse Story-Selling Scheme

    It's revealed the informant had purchased the story from another inmate who was selling it to multiple prisoners for profit.

  9. 29:05Jailhouse Snitch Testimony and Its Limits

    Discussion of why the information wasn't used in court and the unreliability of purchased jailhouse information.

  10. 32:34ICE Enforcement and the Minneapolis Metro Surge

    Travis discusses ATF's involvement in immigration enforcement surges and the agency's limited role compared to DHS.

  11. 35:34Minnesota Daycare Fraud Case

    A brief detour into the Minnesota daycare fraud prosecutions and their origins under the previous administration.

  12. 37:19Analyzing the ICE Shooting Incidents

    Travis gives his perspective on why ICE agents may have been unprepared for high-risk enforcement situations.

  13. 40:13Minnesota's Political Landscape

    The hosts and Travis discuss the stark urban-rural political divide in Minnesota.

  14. 42:13Suppressors, Short-Barrel Rifles, and the 4473 Changes

    Travis explains recent legal shifts allowing easier purchase of suppressors and short-barreled firearms.

  15. 47:38What ATF Agents Actually Do

    Travis outlines ATF's modern focus on violent crime, gang networks, and crime gun intelligence centers.

  16. 50:08Lessons from Waco and the Branch Davidians

    Travis reflects on how past ATF failures, including Waco, shaped current training and tactics.

  17. 52:11Farewell to Travis Riddle

    The hosts thank Travis for joining and he reflects on missing his ATF colleagues but enjoying retirement's quiet.

  18. 53:56Case Recap: Michael Bates and Eddie Joe Sutton

    Post-interview, the hosts summarize the background on the alleged homicide victim and suspect from the earlier jailhouse story.

  19. 58:16Fantasy Football Wrap-Up and Sign-Off

    The episode closes with lighthearted fantasy football talk and a farewell from the hosts.

Q&A

Why didn't federal prosecutors use the homicide evidence in Barouche's sentencing?

The US Attorney's Office feared Judge McBride would not view favorably the fact that the information was purchased from another inmate, so they declined to introduce it despite deeming it substantial assistance to the government.

How was the murder victim's cranium discovered?

While walking back from an unsuccessful day-long search using rebar to probe disturbed dirt, the team spotted a cranium sitting on top of the ground as they were leaving the search area.

How quickly did the ATF canine locate the firearm?

The handler and canine were on scene for about fifteen minutes before locating the gun within a quarter-mile vicinity that Riddle had narrowed down.

What was the victim's identity and the murder suspect's history?

The victim was Michael Bates from Abilene, who went missing in 2004. Suspect Eddie Joe Sutton was serving a twenty-year federal sentence for bank robbery and was later convicted of stabbing another inmate while incarcerated.

Episode notes

Retired ATF Special Agent in Charge Travis Riddle returns to Signal 51 Chronicles with hosts Jake White and John Henry to close out the Colleyville bombing case, revealing a bizarre twist involving a jailhouse informant who sold a fabricated murder confession story for $10,000 that somehow led investigators to an actual skeletal remains and murder weapon in rural Texas. The conversation widens into Riddle’s insider perspective on the ATF, covering the ICE metro surge and shootings in Minneapolis-St. Paul, recent changes to suppressor and short-barrel rifle regulations, the agency’s evolving fight against violent gun crime, and lasting lessons from the 1993 Waco Branch Davidian raid. True crime fans will not want to miss this deep dive into federal law enforcement, cold case twists, and real stories from inside the ATF.

Read Transcript

This is the Signal 51 Chronicles. I'm John Henry. To the left of me here is my compadre, Jake White, a subject matter expert as a retired I did not sergeant for the police department.

Ever. Good lord. We come to you from an undisclosed location in Fort Worth, Texas as part of the Sunset Lounge DFW.

We do true crime here. Do it every week, most weeks. Most weeks, yeah.

We peel back the onion on the macabre. On the other side of us is our producer, Ashley, the Hood County Hellcat. Yes.

Yes. Yep. Whose whereabouts on many a night remains unaccounted for.

Yep. I'm not saying it's suspicious, but who knows, one day. Yep.

For real. Yeah, one day. One day we'll have Down there in the old Hood County.

You ain't gonna believe this. Yeah. I think you struck a weird turn on signal 51.

We should just make up a story about me and do a full episode on it. Yeah. We could.

And have people get interested in it, and nobody's able to find anything but y'all. Exactly. Where would we be without Ashley, is the question.

Perhaps that. Possibly that. I did send you a reminder last night.

Yeah. I made the adult decision to go to bed early. You, on the other hand I didn't.

No. You didn't. Anything crazy happen up there?

Not that I can recall. The usual shenanigans? The usual shenanigans.

Yes. Where you where you begin to tell a story and get interrupted 48 times? That happened.

That might have happened once or twice. Yeah. The usual.

That's fine. Well, let's get on with continuing our conversation with Mr. Travis Riddle, retired ATF SAC.

Yes, do I have that right? You do. Special agent in charge.

Special agent in charge, he's seen a lot of stuff, including our case on the mysterious package that showed up on the doorstep of a soon to be divorce in Colleyville. Yep. All right.

So trial he, never happened in this one, right? No. So he pleaded guilty to that charge of possessing an unregistered destructive device.

He was sentenced by the late judge John McBride, ten years max sentence. So the trial's over. The wife was a little disappointed.

She says, I'm a little disappointed that they're not going after attempted murder in this case. We'll get to that. To cut in right there.

That was that was discussed when... With Colleyville and with the DA's office, which was where are we gonna get the biggest bang for our buck when it comes to our prosecution? And Colleyville's discussion with the DA was, you you're going to have to overcome some hurdles in order to show an attempted murder.

And even if even if we do an attempted murder, I guess, well, you know, even if we get a second degree charge or a third degree charge or a conviction, you know, he's going to be capped at ten years, and he may not even get, you know, a a portion of that because he had no criminal history. And even if he gets a portion of it, you know, based on the Texas criminal justice system, I don't know what the time is now, Jake, but what's he going do? Maybe 30%, 40% if he behaves himself?

And, in the federal system, if you're an ideal prisoner, you're going to do 80%. And so at that time, it was decided to go federally and not state. If it had gone if the DA had said, I think we can do better than the ten years, it would have gone state.

But during those conversations on on strategies that we just made a determination that that we we thought there was gonna be a bigger hammer, in the federal system. That that... Quick side note on that.

This is right around the same time you'll recall this when Sean Harris got shot on the search warrant over off of campus and I-twenty, kind of brought over by that TCC campus, right? Basically in between there and OD White High School. Yeah, Wichita Street and Yeah.

Back then. So we had developed probable cause for a search warrant. We had an undercover officer go into the house, guns everywhere.

The undercover officer we used, no longer on the department, but one of the best undercovers I've ever seen in my life. He grew up in in, he grew up in South Dallas, you know, not a kid of the streets, he's kind of a cop nerd, but he could play a kid of the streets, if you will, and so he goes into this house to buy weed or crack or whatever it was back then, and when he walks in, there's a guy that points an AR-fifteen at his head, just standard practice for this dope house, I suppose. And he comes out and he is freaked out.

And this guy does not get freaked out on undercover deals, never. And so our boss is like, hey, we probably need to hit it sooner rather than later, so go ahead and type the warrant up, we'll call SWAT in. And, you know, the SWAT tactics were different then than they are now.

And so they bring out all the stuff they never used to bring out, like the bear cat, the armored vehicle, shields, the whole nine yards. And so they're gonna make entry through the garage and through the front door, kind of a dual hit, if you will, or simultaneous entry. And so they go in and me, Mike Valdez, rest in peace, and a few other guys are standing two yards over in the front yard.

And we were the furthest thing from SWAT operators. We use what I call a wild banshee technique whenever we did run our warrants. There was no real plan to it, no real technique, just a lot of luck.

Flying by the seat of your pants. Flying by the seat of our pants. And we always knew when SWAT was there, let them do their thing because we'll probably F it up if we get right.

So all of a sudden we hear what I think are flashbangs going off and I see Mike Valdez take off running towards the house and I'm like, dude, what are you doing? Like, we're going get yelled at by the SWAT commander. And he was kind of a, a good dude, like kind of a legendary SWAT commander, but his tolerance for our bullshit was slim to none.

And all of a sudden, I see one of the SWAT guys, Sean Harris, another kind of legendary SWAT guy come, like, dead legging out of the garage. And the SWAT commander pulls up. Man, dude, it looks like a scene straight out of a war movie, man.

He hoists them up over his shoulder and they're limping down the street and Sean's laying in the street. And we have the paramedics there at the time. Now have their own.

The police department now has their own, but at the time it was fire department, and so Sean's laying in the street and you'd see just leg covered in blood, so in those green BDUs that they had, and I remember I'm looking, and Sean's a tough guy, dude, I mean, he's a big guy, good dude, and he's just laying there, and I'm like, Damn, dude, he got shot, and he's just laying there cooler than the other side of the pillow, and I'm like, Man, there's no way that would be my reaction if I got shot. I'd be freaking out. I would probably actually ruin my career and reputation.

They'd be like, nah, dude, we saw behind the curtains. We know how you respond. Luckily, that never happened to me.

So I'm laying there, or he's laying there and I'm just standing there. I don't know what to do. The paramedics working on him, and I remember he looks up and there's like four of us standing around.

He's like, Guys, this is not good. I'm like, it might have hit his carotid artery or femoral artery, sorry. And I'm like, I don't know if you should have said, guys, this is not good.

And so anyway, he goes to hospital, he lives, he's went back to SWAT for many, many years. He may be retired now, I'm not for sure. But with that being said, this is a violent drug house, and we're tying this back to this difference between state prosecution and federal prosecution.

Do you remember where I'm going with this, Travis? Yep. Okay, so these guys are all prime candidates to be prosecuted under the federal system.

Most of them had lengthy violent criminal histories. There was a ton of dope and a ton of guns inside that house. They shot two officers, they hit another one, not to diminish it, they hit him in the hand, he was holding the shield, so I don't know if it was like a ricochet or whatever it was, so he shoots two police officers or one of the suspects in there shoots two police officers and I'm there and I'm like, man, I'm gonna call Travis, dude.

This is like, this has gone beyond what we need to be, my mind immediately goes to, okay, the sentence these guys are going to get is going to be relatively minimal in the state system compared to the federal system. And Travis, correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe you made some calls and they're like, no, no, no, no, we want this one, we're gonna throw the book at these guys. And so one of them, his name was Pistol Pete was the main suspect, that was his nickname, obviously.

They really threw the book at him, man. He was in custody for about two years leading up to trial. He got sentenced to, I believe, nine years.

He had a deadly weapon enhancement, so he would have to have served 50% of his sentence, but because he was already in custody for two years, he still had to serve another two and a half years. So in short, he was basically out of prison two two and a half years after his court date. It's a guy who shot a police Shot two police officers.

Two police officers. Yeah. Or involved.

Pistol Pete was not the shooter. Okay. One of them...

Two... What didn't... One of them was TCU football player at one point.

Right? Yes. Yeah.

I have to look that up. I can't remember who who it was. I don't think I I don't think he had a long tenured career playing there at TCU, but still.

Going back to that, that's one of the, on the fed system, like I see the wife's frustration, right? Like he only got ten years, but even if there was some kind of criminal attempt, murder, whatever the charge would have been, he's not doing ten years. And we're going to get into a sentence in a little bit, cause the story takes another turn that's insanity, but Was there talks...

Because I think the McBride said something to the effect that he would have liked to have given him twenty five years, but according to the law, he could not. In there like an upward departure? Walk us through that again.

So, yeah, the... You know, the... In the federal system, there's guidelines for for sentencing, and it's it's it's a it's a formula that pretrial services does.

I mean, it can go, I mean, they're they're looking at his criminal history, they're looking at, you know, his childhood. It's all these numbers they put together, and it goes into a calculation. And then in that calculation, it gives the judge a recommended, a sentence window of what they feel would be recommended.

But it's just a recommendation. The judge he doesn't have to stick to that, and he... And often judges don't do that.

And, you know, well within their rights, sometimes, you know, there's mitigating circumstances that they they feel are are important, and they will go below the guidelines. And oftentimes, there's circumstances that aggravate the crime, and they'll go above the guidelines. And, you know, I I had been in judge Mac Pride's court many many times.

And, you know, he was always, you know, very... He was always very... He was pretty he was pretty strict on his sentencings.

But when Wright was right, I definitely did see him downward depart. And when Wright was right, I'd seen him upward depart. But in this particular case, he could not upward depart because he was capped by statute.

So the maximum sentence for that for that crime was ten years, and he he could not exceed what the statute was. And so, you know, if if there had been a a wider range of of potential terms of incarceration, he definitely could have gone above the guidelines. But in this case, ten years was the most he could give him.

So yeah, Judge McBride had a reputation for being very stern in the courtroom. Oh, yeah. Find one attorney $300 for...

I just... I was remembering to look it up for finding an attorney $300 for arriving twelve minutes late to a hearing. I'll I'll tell you one even funnier.

And I can't... Maybe... I don't know, Jake, if you were on that one.

It was one it was a it was one of those houses in Como. What was that guy's name? It doesn't make any difference.

Anyway, same situation. I think it was one that DA hit, and there, you know, there were some dope, but there wasn't like like a whole lot of dope. But there was lots of guns, and the criminal histories were were pretty were pretty bad on these guys.

And so both of those guys were taken into custody, and and the main dude was getting ready for trial. And so, I mean, when I say getting ready for trial, like like the jury is gonna be picked. So this is the day of of selecting a jury.

And the marshals bring in the defendant, and he's in his orange jumpsuit, which in trial, you don't wear orange jumpsuits. You want to wear normal clothing because you don't want to sway the... You don't wanna make the jury think the guy's already guilty because he's in an orange jumpsuit.

Right? But he's in an orange jumpsuit, and typically, the clothing stuff is arranged by the defense attorney. And so before the trial even starts and before the jury selection starts, judge McBride is asking the defense attorney on how come his client's not properly dressed.

And so, he's like, well, I contacted the family and just went a whole... Went down a whole line of reasons why the... His defendant was not properly in proper attire, which then devolved into the conversation of, Counselor, how many federal trials have you participated in?

And the answer was none. And then the next question was, Counselor, how did you get in my court? And at that point, you know, the trial was delayed until a new attorney could be assigned.

Yeah. If you if you if you remember those old, know, wanna get away commercials from Southwest Airlines. One of them right there.

And if I had given that defense attorney a shovel, I'm fairly confident he could have dug a hole deep enough to jump into to get to get away to get away from that hire. Once again, was not funny at the time. Now Now it is.

Now it's pretty funny. Yeah. I felt I felt so bad for that guy.

Yeah. I'm sure. Okay.

So David, ten years. Where does he... Where is he doing his time at?

Do you remember where he... What FMT he was at or or what penitentiary he's at? I know I know prior to sentencing, like many like many defense, their house at FCI Fort Worth, I'm not positive if he ever left FCI Fort Worth.

That, you know, to tell you the truth, after the case was done, I'd I'd... It, you know, I'm moving on to the next case. I really don't know where he did his, his sentencing, but for some reason, I wanna say that I don't think he ever left.

But don't hold me to that. I'm not positive. So he's got ten years.

He's gonna have to do, you know, a guaranteed eight years. And like you said, most of the time you move on, right? You're on to the next bad guy, to the next case.

You really don't hear a whole lot, but that's not what happened in this one. Right. And on this one, it wasn't it wasn't after sentencing.

This took place before sentencing, like, before sentencing. And so, you know, I get a call from defense attorney, which that's not uncommon. And a defense attorney is like, my client would to be interviewed under a proffer agreement.

If you're not familiar with a proffer agreement is, it's basically, for a better lack of term, it's a contract between the government and the defendant, which tells the defendant, anything you say cannot be used against you, as long as it's true. If it's if it's not true, then everything you say can be used against you. And so, you know, it gives people opportunities to provide the government information, and oftentimes, in exchange for information, motions are put forth by the government to reduce sentencing.

So in this particular case, sentencing, I get the call from the defense attorney that my client would like to talk to you. And of course, I don't know how many times I had done that in my career, but most times it did not amount to anything that was useful. Mostly it was just, you know, let's let's see how much we can throw out there, and maybe something will stick someplace at some point.

And so, you know, I went out to FCI Fort Worth, and, you know, it was was David and his attorney. And at that point, he lays out a tale, to say the least, is something that, back then, was like, there ain't no way this is true. So anyway, he lays out a a story of he has obtained information of where he knows where there is a homicide victim.

He knows the location of where the murder weapon's at, and he also knows, you know, who the suspect is, and the suspect is more than willing to confess once y'all are are able to, you know, track this stuff down. He was also nice enough to provide a map of, you know, where all these... All this was supposed to be at.

So, you know, being the typical cop, you know, very skeptical of how valid any of this is. And so it was very shortly after that conversation with him, one of the other agents in the office was heading out West to take care of some business, which happened to be in the same vicinity of where this map was supposed to be, telling us where this stuff is at. So I just asked him if I could just tag along.

And when he got finished, can we drive a little bit farther north and just see if this map takes us anywhere? So long story short, the map takes us exactly where the map said it was gonna take us, which once again, now you're starting to think maybe this thing has some legs. And so, you know, when I get back to Fort Worth, I call one of my ranger buddies and tell him the story.

And of course, you know, his level of disbelief was probably, you know, the same level as mine when I went to originally... Went to FCI to talk to David. But was like, nothing for nothing.

We have to go out there. We at least have to make an attempt to to at least see if there's somebody, a victim out there. So we planned another trip.

So it was me, the ranger, and at the time it was the undersheriff for Anson County. And so we proceed to walk through, best way I can say, the Texas scrub searching for a shallow grave. I think we were out there we were out there all day, and, you know, nothing.

I mean, we're walking around with rebar, you know, because anytime we would see a disturbed area of dirt, we would probe it to see, you know, if there if there was any any voids in it that might indicate that, you know, that there were something underneath. But we did that all day, and we came up with nothing. It was it was frustrating because everything else had checked out.

So at that point, we're getting kind of towards the evening. We're like, you know, let's... We've we've done what we can do.

Let's let's call it good. And so we're walking back, and, you know, whether it was divine intervention or just pure luck, there was a cranium sitting on top of the ground as we're walking back. And that's what we said.

And we're like, what are the odds? Because when you think about that part of Texas just north of Abilene, there shouldn't have been anything left. I mean, you've got pigs.

You've got everything down there. So, you know, so, you know, the undersheriff called in some some deputies to to secure the area. And, you know, I think it was the ranger who had the great idea of contacting University of North Texas because they had a forensic anthropology school.

And so they came out and... The next day and basically did a dig much as you would do for, you know, any type of, you know, archaeological, you know, items that you were looking for. I mean, just layer by layer.

Had the cadaver dogs out there. At the end of the day, the only thing we found at that scene was just the cranium. But once that was wrapped up, we've got the other portion of the map, which was, you know, allegedly where this firearm is supposed to be located.

You know, it definitely was not an x mark to the spot. It was kind of a general vicinity. And once again, we're we're not in a heavy populated area, you know, extremely rural.

I mean, you're not seeing residences anywhere. It's just it's just, you know, rangeland for all intents and purposes. But we did have a road that kind of gave us a guide on maybe kind of going this direction.

So instead of, you know, doing it the old fashioned way of let's go out there and, you know, walk through the scrub and hopefully we stumble across something, I decided to call our ATF canine. And what... You know, people, you know, if they've ever seen the canine, I mean, they're they're...

Most of them are black labs or, you know, they're they're blonde labs, super nice dogs, and they're trying to find explosives. But what a lot of people don't understand is those dogs are also trained to find firearms. And so a handler came out.

I said, I think this is kind of the general vicinity. It was about a it was about a... I think the closest I could narrow it down was about a quarter mile.

I couldn't get it any closer than that. That was out there maybe fifteen minutes, there you go. Found the gun.

And so secured that as evidence. So now we have a, you know, we have a we have a cranium. We have suspected homicide weapon.

And so myself and the ranger at that point left and went straight back to FCI Fort Worth to interview the the supposed the killer. So Okay. So you guys go...

This is where it gets even, I don't know, to me, just even wilder. So walk us through how Baruch got that information to you. So when when he was when he was proffered, he disclosed that he had purchased this information from this other inmate.

And, of course, at the time, you don't know, but later that was corroborated by the the inmate who provided the information. But evidently, he had provided similar stories to many other inmates. He was attempting to try to get as much money as he could because I think at that time, he was in poor health and, you know, he was looking for means to to take care of...

I believe it was his daughter. And so, you know, I I think he I think he tried to sell that story many times because even after even after this case was said and done, I was still getting calls from from FCI Fort Worth about other, you know you know, farfetched stories and lo and behold, it's the same guy generating them, you know. So...

Yeah. But that's how I got it. He he paid for it.

And, you know, when, you know, course, the results of the efforts out there in the Ensign County, all that's relayed to the US attorney. Because once again, all this information stemmed from a proffer. So in my mind, that is substantial assistance to the government to potentially solve a homicide.

Even if it's not a federal offense, it's still it's still assistance to the government. And so everything that was discovered out there, all of our findings was relayed to the US attorney's office, and their decision was not to introduce that into court in fears that judge McBride would not look kindly on the fact that the information was purchased. And so, you know, I did...

I mean, I petitioned the best I could on David's behalf. And I know for a while, I don't think that was the perception, his perception. But I did all I could.

They... The US Attorney's Office had all the facts. And Jake knows from experience, you know, what I say and what I'm gonna do.

And and that's exactly what I did do. But unfortunately, I'm not the one that makes the decision on making recommendations for upward or downward departures. So...

Okay. So in in in summary on that, so inmate... So Barouche buys this story from the other...

For, like, $10,000, wasn't it? I believe it was $10,000. Dude's pedaling the truth.

He's pedaling his own true crime story and actually making money because it was reported to other other agencies. Right? Just nobody followed up on it.

Right. And, you know, if it was shortly before, I learned about this information from the proffer, I was in judge McBride's court, awaiting a sentencing, And DEA had a a defendant that was being sentenced, judge McBride properly departed him. And he was not...

You know, the defendant was not happy about that. And he made some, you know, he made some statements that he had information about a homicide and guns and all this kind of stuff. Well, lo and behold, it was the same story that that David had purchased, and just at the time nobody knew.

And so, you know, fast forward a few months after all this has taken place. Once again, that same story keeps popping up from from different from different inmates. So how many times this guy sold that story?

I don't have any idea. I don't... I mean, it it was multiples.

So Yeah. That's... Oh, man.

Yeah. That that was one of the crazy turns on this case. I mean, actually, I mean, because you get those jailhouse statements a lot and you I mean, you have you've got to take them with a grain of salt because the motivation is for somebody to get their sentence reduced or get out or whatever.

So most of the time, they're be there. I don't I think there are some states. I don't even know if they allow jailhouse snitch testimony.

I mean, it's very, like, very controlled, you know, because of the the motivation behind it. So And so he ultimately did not get his... He he did not get a bang for his buck on this.

No. He he didn't get anything for it. Just No.

And and I know I know that was a... I know he he did not particularly care for that, and I absolutely don't blame him for that. You know, whether it was purchased or whether it wasn't purchased, the fact is he provided the information.

The information was beneficial, and I felt that he he should have gotten some type of credit for it, but the the US attorney's office felt different. Did you ever have any, contact with the the wife after this going back to Jeanette or just, I mean, just kind of a normal case where you didn't really have much interaction with her or anything? Very limited, because, you know, shortly after all this kind of finalized, I left.

And so I know resident resident agent in charge for Fort Worth at the time was was still communicating with Jeanette over some concerns. And so, you know, he would call me and say, hey. Do you know about this or you know about that?

And and so that went on for a while. And, you know, slowly slowly but surely, things just started quieting down to where I just didn't hear anything again. Well, I think that's a good wrap on that story.

I do think there's a few other things that are kind of cool to get into though, you're For sure, you're so inclined. If you're so inclined. Because Minneapolis St.

Paul, of course, has been the center of some matters of immigration and ICE and so forth. Boy, I'll say all sorts of stuff up there. But Travis, I wanted to ask you about that.

What has been described as the metro surge up there, and of course, an ice shooting. Two ice, there were two of them up there, weren't there? Three of them.

Three of them. Okay. So how close were you to that situation or those situations in Minneapolis St.

Paul? So when the new administration took over, immigration became the priority. It became a priority to the point to where DOJ law enforcement agencies were given title and authority, which is immigration authority.

We never had that. We didn't do immigration. We didn't know anything about immigration.

But we were given that authority to make arrest based on immigration violations. So as far as the enforcement, of course, I mean, DHS has the number of agents and employees that they have compared to ATF. I mean, it's it's exponentially larger.

So there were levels of participation, but, you know, it was always at a reduced capacity. We just... We don't have the bodies to be able to do, what the DHS entities can do, just for the simple lack of numbers.

When you say, the shift, I mean, were you... Was this impacting the the normal day to day operations for you guys? In the beginning, it was.

I don't know how much impact it had in in other divisions. The Saint Paul field division, you know, I would not call that division fat with employees as far as agents. You know, if you start looking at larger divisions like, you know, maybe Houston or Dallas, I don't think it had quite the same impact.

But for us, specifically in Minnesota, not so much in Wisconsin or the Dakotas, but in Minnesota, it was recurring significant portion of our investigative time was immigration. Wasn't wasn't it wasn't it up there that they had... Was it up there or or in Michigan?

I think it was in Minnesota. The the the corruption with the the kids school. Right?

Wasn't that up there? Monday? Daycares.

Daycares. Yeah. Wasn't that up there?

Yeah. Yeah. But you know, if we're if we're if we're having an honest discussion about the narrative, the prosecutions for that was taking place before...

I mean, I think that case started with the Biden administration. So there were already defendants that were being prosecuted for that before, you know, this this became the the forefront for the fraud and corruption in Minnesota. The previous US attorney's office had already started aggressively prosecuting those cases.

So, you know, it wasn't a new focus. It was just a continued focus on on the same on the same group of individuals. And so, you know, as time went on, you know, they're getting more and more convictions, but most of that stuff started before, you know, the change of the guard.

So, it just became more it just became more prominent in the news, than than it had been in the past. Got it. So Jake and I have just...

We had this discussion on a few occasions about some of the things ICE had been kind of asked to do, excuse me, that might've led to the shooting incidents up there, primarily as it regards enforcement and crowd control, I think, is what we discussed. It was just something like they were encountering that they had just typically don't, which led, we think, to some of these shootings, right? You know, I don't, I mean, look, those guys are, are, they're put, they're be, they were in positions where they're, they're rapidly evolving, right?

From a tactics perspective, a lot of what you see is not, you know, if you're a twenty year cop, like going up to a car or making those arrests are pretty routine. You know, it's not an, I don't know the training, I don't know how it works for those. I mean, I don't know, I'm trying to think of how to frame this, but I think that with a lot of them, they're put in these positions and some of them may not have had the experience.

Right. I guess in short, could these incidents have been prevented up there? I think that's a complete unknown.

I don't think there's any way to predict if things could have been prevented. My perspective at the time is that, you know, the the men and women of of DHS, whether it be ICE, Border Patrol, HSI, you know, CVP, whatever whatever agency they're they're working for at DHS, they're just as dedicated as any agent or employee for DOJ. There's no difference.

The difference lies into how you are trained and what your normal day to day functions are. And my opinion is that when ICE was put in a position for the type of enforcement mission that they were sent on, that's not what they're trained for. It's just not.

It it wouldn't have been any different to ask patrol officers in Minneapolis to go do high risk dynamic warrants like a SWAT team would. The SWAT teams are the SWAT teams are trained for that. And so it would be much safer and better planned out.

And so I think this was a similar situation of of not necessarily ill intent, but maybe lack of experience and proper training. Would that would that have fixed anything? I don't know.

I mean, because, you know, you also have to think at the same time that, you know, the the narrative and the dialogue that is going in the country at that point is that, know, DHS was very emboldened to do things because they were... They had complete support of the administration. And believe they still do.

And so I I think it I think it gave them a sense of confidence that maybe they could work outside their comfort level a little more than maybe they would usually do because they they thought they would be covered if anything went sideways. Minnesota's always had... Their politics are just kind of crazy.

I mean, you you got this... Who was the wrestler that was the governor there? Jesse Ventura.

Jesse Ventura. And then, of course, you got this crazy Tim Walls who looks like a, of a nutty professor type guy. What is the climate up there with I mean, just in general, what's the political climate up there?

Because that's the other thing they're throwing ice into is enforcement in this this kind of eccentric state that has just kind of crazy politics. You know, the the interesting thing about Minnesota is, you know, and it's much like it's much like if you were to look at any of the other states, you know, the higher concentration of population typically are Democratic voters. So in the state of Minnesota, when you look at the population centers, you're looking at Minneapolis, Saint Paul, Rochester, Duluth.

You know, those are the places that have the most people. Therefore, they have the most most voters. If you get out into the counties just outside those metros, it is it is not the same vibe.

More conservative. Yeah. I would not say more.

I would say extremely. Okay. It's it's it's it's very interesting that you don't have to get that far out of the cities to have a complete change of view on the politics as you're as you're just driving.

And so, you know, you know, the way our elections are held, you know, most votes win. So the most most votes are, you know, in those population centers. And so therefore, you know, you know, the the Democratic Party typically is very successful in Minnesota.

Jake, you'd mentioned earlier about the... What you what you described, the four four seven three short short barrel suppressors. Could could we get Travis to talk about that for Yeah.

That's an interesting Yeah. Intro that. What what exactly So in summary, and and I'm not the gun guru by...

In any way, shape, or form. So Travis, step in if I misspeak. But in summary, historically, if you're going to buy a short barreled rifle and you've got to get a tax stamp, it has to go to an FFL, federal firearms license or a gun store, and then you're going to pick it up from there.

Right? Well, now when you go, let's say you're going to go to whatever gun store and buy an AR 15, you fill out what are from an FFL, you fill out what they call a forty four seventy three. That's just that questionnaire, making sure that, you know, you're not a...

That you're, you know, you don't have a history of drug use and all the other questions that they have on there. And they do the quick background check, and typically that day you walk out with the gun. Well, that wasn't the case with the short barreled rifles or with the suppressors.

But that's changed now. Correct, Travis? Correct.

So, you know, one of the district courts made made a decision that they felt that part of the NFA law, which is what governed these type of items, was unconstitutional. Whether you agree, whether you disagree, that's court's decision. But typically, when a federal court says that a law is unconstitutional, typically, the government will appeal that decision.

And in this case, they opted not to. And so that's kinda changed the perspective of the federal government when it comes to the short barrel shotguns and suppressors and short barrel rifles, is that, you know, ATF has decided, I'm I'm sure with legal guidance, that they're not going to prosecute individuals who obtain these items through the guidelines that have been kind of laid out, which is now... You just fill out a forty four seventy three, just like Jake said.

So if you wanna go into a store and they've had suppressors and they have, you know, whatever the gun you're looking for, and, you know, you're legally, you know, able to purchase it, and you walk out the same day, you know, with those items, you know, whether you agree or disagree. You know, that's, you know, that's what's happening now. You know, and my personal opinion is I think this is long overdue.

I think this should have taken place a long time ago of having suppressors and the short barrel items removed from the NSA. Jake, I don't know about you, but, I never worked a federal case that ever involved a suppressor. Yeah.

No. I mean, all those things are so rare. You know?

I mean, it's... Now I think some of the... I don't know with like, you know, obviously the Glock switches and stuff like that that are being illegally or manufactured on three d printers.

I don't know if the same applies with suppressors. I'm not in that world right now, so I don't know. Oh, yeah.

I mean, it's, you know, I I also have just a possession, type offense of having a short barrel rifle or a shotgun or a suppressor used in a crime. I've never worked one. I'm sure there's somebody out there, but, I mean, it's just not common...

Commonly used. And so I I thought it's surely at some point before I retired that Congress would amend the NFA statute and just remove those items, But they haven't, and they still and they still haven't. And so, you know, that's still on the books.

Now, of course, the the window for the for the government to appeal that district court's decision has come and gone, but that doesn't prevent a different administration of, you know, finding a different case to bring forth and then appeal it that way. And so I'd be interested, you know, in the future if there is a change in administrations as far as, you know, Democrat versus Republican, if this is not reopened. And then how do you clean that up?

Because, you know, the statute is still is still there. It hasn't been invalidated. It's just been consciously decided that it's not gonna be enforced.

It's not really any different than previous administration who decided they weren't going to do a lot of immigration enforcement. So... Which is, you know, you know, that is part of the privilege of the executive branch, is to have prosecutorial priorities.

They enforce they enforce the law if they decide they don't want to. They don't they don't do it. So and so, you know, the priorities for the previous administration was not immigration.

The priorities for this administration is immigration. And whether you agree or disagree, that is well within their rights. And so under that same umbrella, they have made a decision that, you know, that this portion of the NFA will not be enforced.

The whenever we talk or whenever you hear ATF, it's these conversations that often get brought up. My... Whenever I picture them, it's not like these conversations don't enter my mind.

So kind of give us an idea of just through your perspective, what do ATF agents do? What's their bread and butter? So, you know, and and that's that's evolved from when I started, to when I retired.

So if you were to if you were to look at, what that agency's main focus is right now, it is combating violent farm offenses. That's the focus. They're using the traditional techniques that Jake and I used, which are probably antiquated at this point.

But they're also using a lot of new technologies like NIBIN and crime gun intelligence centers to better network the different agencies together. So they're all talking about the same things. And that's, you know, for example, up here in the Twin Cities, you know, there's there's been ongoing gang violence.

I'm sure you've seen it in the news. You know, the the the deal with those gangs is they're very transient. They're not like traditional gangs where, you know, this is my block and, you know, this is what we're gonna protect.

They may live in a completely different city, but Minneapolis typically is the cultural hub for many of these gangs. And so that's often where their disagreements are settled. And so it's...

It was becoming increasingly difficult to try to obtain prosecutions because, you know, the shooting took place in Minneapolis, but, you know, the individuals live, you know, in a different suburb, in a different county. And so, you know, those agencies are not communicating with each other because they're not on the same databases. And and so those are things that ATF is trying to help with is to connect everyone together so everyone's communicating to have a clearer picture to address that violent crime.

So that... That's really the... That's the bread and butter now.

You know, preventing firearm violence was, of course, the reason that ATF raided the Branch Davidians in 1993. I'm assuming that was a little before your time. No, was breathing on this earth, but I was no, I was not in law enforcement at that time.

Did that raid become a test study for you guys over the years? Kind of went wrong that day? Other than being tipped off, I know they had been You tipped know, if...

And, you know, I can't speak for other agencies, but I know, as far as ATF is is concerned, you know, when there's significant events, you know, such as such as Waco, and mistakes are made, just like you said, those mistakes are studied. You know, why did they take place? What could we have done better?

And oftentimes what happens is then then that is that is then pushed out to our training. So things like that don't happen again. And, Jake, if you remember, I mean, for years and years and years, I mean I mean, when you were working patrol, I know when I was working patrol.

If you were standing in front of a car and someone was driving towards you, you were probably okay to use deadly force because they were trying to hit you. You know, ATF took a hard look at that many years ago to figure out where their shootings were coming from. It made the determination that many of their shootings could be mitigated if they just didn't stand in front of cars.

And lo and behold, there was a drastic reduction in shootings. And that happens with with every law enforcement agency is you constantly have to look at what you were doing and how is it working and can we do it better. And way...

Waco was absolutely no different. There, you know, definitely were some mistakes made, but those were case studies on how can we do it better in the future. And even though there was loss of life on both sides, it definitely was a warning scenario for federal law enforcement.

All right. I think we've taken enough time of mister Travis Riddle. I agree.

Fascinating conversation. Yeah. Very much so.

And very grateful for your, willingness to come on. Yep. Appreciate it.

Came the excuse to do something on Sunday. That's right. On a lazy Sunday.

On a lazy Sunday. On a lazy Sunday. Hopefully, least your phone's not gonna be ringing.

Your phone's not gonna be ringing. No, it's not. No.

No. I was telling Jake that's been the hardest thing to get used to. It's just like it's quiet.

My phone hardly rings now. And before it was, you know, especially right before I retired, it was just... I mean, it was constant.

I was on the phone all the time. So that that that silence is weird of not having to keep that phone in your pocket all the time because you don't know what the next, you know, next emergency is gonna be. No.

No. I don't... No.

No. I I mean, the... And and Jake can probably understand.

I, you know, I I miss I miss the people I worked with, whether they started whether I was when I was an agent or when I was a sack. There's just some phenomenal people in ATF. And they're all focused on the same mission, which is to keep people safe.

Regardless if people believe that or not, you haven't been to my shoes. You haven't seen what I've seen. And I know that's what ATF does.

But as far as the the hustle and bustle and the pace and, I haven't, no, I haven't got to the point yet where I missed that. I'm I'm enjoying the the calm and the quiet for now. The remains of Michael Bates.

Michael Bates. Michael Bates. Who is Michael Bates?

Bates went missing. He's from Abilene, went missing from Abilene in 2,004. Eddie Joe Sutton, the inmate that sold the story to Barouche, obviously was the suspect in that, was initially serving a twenty year federal prison sentence for bank robbery.

He, I'm assuming this, if it was at... If he was in Fort Worth, it may have been a medical issue or something like that. While he...

While Eddie Joe Sutton was incarcerated, he had also been accused, well, I guess convicted of stabbing another inmate. Yeah. So that's the body they found, that was that story.

Now, as far as what happened, well, hang on, let me... I can... I remember what he told us on that, so...

Okay. Yeah. So motives, what what did Travis say about the motives in regards to the murder?

They weren't exactly sure. As you mentioned that Eddie Joe Sutton was serving a sentence on bank robbery. And Michael and Mr.

Bates was apparently probably homeless, transient. He was said to have a substance drug problem. And the detectives in the case could only hypothesize what was, the motive, but they believe that it was a bad sexual encounter is what I'm understanding.

Then this... His story, though, was also that he was being robbed. So the guy That he...

The... Okay. Yeah.

So... Yeah. So Eddie Joe Sutton claimed that he was being robbed.

Oh. But the investigator didn't necessarily believe that story. They think it was some sort of sexual encounter gone wrong.

You know one other thing we forgot to talk about with Travis, and he didn't bring it up, but going back to when Jeanette found that box, under the box was a folded Right. Dollar bill. Yes.

And as Baruch implied, it was meant to be the last dollar bill you ever get from him. Yep. The last dollar.

So... Well, very interesting. Some twists and turns to it that are unusual, but many of those cases, that's how they that's how they shake out.

Well, and, you know, like you said, you know, these divorces go haywire and they turn people nuts. I mean, what good is gonna come from killing your ex wife? None.

And as we're... You know, I think a fitting quote. Soon to be ex wife.

Soon to be ex wife. Yeah, that thing started in like 2008, the divorce proceedings. Long time.

Yeah. A quote from another Eddie Sutton. Arkansas basketball coach, Kentucky.

Oklahoma State. That's correct. Eddie Sutton.

That's correct. That's where I knew him from. Sorry, I didn't dive off into the history books on Eddie Sutton's career.

Arkansas, Kentucky. Here we go. Oklahoma State.

Oh god, okay. That Eddie Sutton said, quote, always have faith in God, yourself, and the Cowboys. He was not talking about the Dallas Cowboys, though.

No one has any faith in Dallas Cowboys. No. They don't.

So What? Are you kidding me? Alright.

Alright. I guess that will be a wrap on That wraps it up. This episode of the Signal 51 Chronicles.

Yep. We got... In fact, we gotta go watch the cowboys.

Yes. Well They're they're actually going right now as we speak. Let's see how they're doing.

By the way, I do love this. I have been climbing the ranks of How do you know I've been cutting this off of every episode just so just so people don't know that you've been running a ruse on them? I am now...

We are now in second place. We're playing Ziggy today. If we win, we will be in first place.

Oh, wow. We are... Well, shit.

No. We just... We gotta have Drake May just kill it.

There's... Oh, man. Jonathan Taylor's effing us.

If Drake May... So we're, Ziggy's got one zero five. We're at 76.

He's got a 60% win probability, but that's gonna change. Tyler Loop fucked us or is. That old packers defense did us a solid 18 points.

Ja'Marr Chase, 20 points. McBride, we still got some time. So we've got a hope for a strong turnout by a one Drake May.

Thank god he's playing the freaking Miami Dolphins. Oh, yeah. I don't even know.

Are they even professional at this? They're going well. They're, you know.

They are, but they're hard. Yeah. So there's a good chance...

I mean, there's a good chance we're gonna be we're gonna be in first place after this... After Monday. Alright.

Well, you heard it here first. We'll be in first place come Monday. Yeah.

Alright. See you guys later. Adios.

This is a Stolen Water Media production.

Scroll to Top